19 Best Rums for Eggnog in 2024 [Perfect Boozy Combinations]

Eggnog, the classic holiday beverage that has been warming chilly winter nights for centuries, is undeniably one of the most beloved seasonal treats. A rich, creamy base of milk, cream, and sweet spices is what makes this silky concoction legendary, but the crowning glory of a perfect glass of eggnog is undoubtedly a generous splash of fine rum.

Choosing the best rums for eggnog is essential to creating a smooth and scrumptious drink, ensuring that every sip is imbued with warmth, festivity, and an unmatched depth of flavor that elevates this traditional beverage to heavenly heights. From the darlings of age-old sipping rums to the powerful punch of spiced rums and the unique profiles of signature blends, our carefully curated list of the best rums for eggnog is guaranteed to make your holiday season a true celebration of taste and tradition.

Also Read: Best Gold Rums To Drink

19 Best Rums for Eggnog in 2024

As the festive season of 2023 rolls in, the allure of a creamy and spirited eggnog beckons. With the sheer variety of rums available, it can be a delightful challenge to find the perfect blend for this classic holiday treat. Dive in as we unveil the 19 best rums that will elevate your eggnog to unparalleled heights this year.

1. El Dorado 12 Year Rum [Best Eggnog Aged Rum]

El Dorado 12 Year Rum originated from Guyana, a small but proud nation on South America's northeastern coast. The aging process of this amber-colored treat takes 12 long years, resulting in a fantastic balance of fruitiness, smoke, and a soft hint of nuts. The palate showcases a rich, creamy texture, with toffee and vanilla notes, complemented by tropical fruits and a subtle spiciness. The finish, long and satisfying, leaves you with a warming sensation of caramel and oak.

When paired with eggnog, El Dorado 12 Year Rum brings a harmonious blend of sweet and spice to the mix, enhancing the overall experience. This aged rum creates genuinely delightful eggnog, with its caramel and toffee undertones adding depth and complexity to the beverage.

2. Appleton Estate 12-Year

Appleton Estate 12-Year boasts of its Jamaican roots, reflecting the unique climate, craftsmanship, and flavors of the island nation. This deeply amber-hued rum features a complex mix of lingering aromas that include apricot, roasted nuts, and traces of oak. On the palate, you'll notice a delicate balance of spicy and fruity flavors, with orange peel, cinnamon, and hints of molasses.

The Appleton Estate 12-Year, when introduced to a glass of eggnog, transforms it into an irresistible holiday indulgence. The rum's fruity and spicy notes meld seamlessly with the creamy and sweet qualities of the eggnog, enveloping your taste buds in a blanket of wintertime bliss.

3. El Dorado 8 Year Old Rum

Another exquisite offering from Guyana, the El Dorado 8 Year Old Rum is a younger sibling to its 12-year counterpart. Its golden color and enticing combination of dried fruits, vanilla, and oak on the nose make it a fascinating choice for rum enthusiasts. Flavor-wise, the rum delights with a sweet, slightly smoky profile, hints of caramel, and a mild but appealing spice.

Paired with eggnog, El Dorado 8 Year Old Rum offers a delectable balance of sweetness and oaky character. Its dulcet, smoky notes complement the eggnog beautifully, adding a touch of sophistication and intrigue to the classic holiday concoction.

4. The Diplomatico Rum

The Diplomatico Rum hails from the heart of Venezuela, where it is crafted using time-honored distillation methods and aged in oak barrels. This exquisite rum is known for its nuanced aroma that features hints of tropical fruit, citrus, and vanilla. Upon the first sip, you will be delighted by the rich tapestry of flavors, including notes of caramel, toffee, and just a touch of oakiness, making it a perfect partner for velvety eggnog.

By incorporating Diplomatico into your eggnog, you will not only add a new layer of sophistication to this holiday favorite but also transport your senses to the sun-soaked shores of Latin America. The smooth, well-rounded profile of this rum flawlessly melds with the creamy base of the eggnog, enriching its texture and enhancing the warmth of the spices.

5. Rhum JM VO

Originating from the picturesque Caribbean island of Martinique, Rhum JM VO is an aged agricultural rum steeped in tradition. Produced using fresh sugar cane juice, it undergoes a rigorous distillation process before being aged for a minimum of three years in re-charred bourbon barrels. This unique method imparts a beautiful amber hue to the rum and a distinctive, silky texture.

Rhum JM VO captivates with its enticing bouquet of fruity and floral notes, underscored by delicate hints of spice. This delightful profile perfectly complements the rich character of eggnog, adding an exotic touch to your festive celebration. The refined elegance of Rhum JM VO ensures that each sip of your indulgent eggnog gently lingers on the palate, leaving a lasting impression of sumptuous, tropical serenity.

6. Denizen Merchant's Reserve

A captivating blend of rums from Jamaica and Martinique, Denizen Merchant's Reserve offers a remarkable depth of flavor that elevates even the most ordinary eggnog to an extraordinary delight. This expertly crafted rum is aged for up to eight years in charred oak barrels, imbuing each bottle with a unique richness and complexity.

Denizen Merchant's Reserve is renowned for its harmonious fusion of fruity, floral, and spicy nuances, each flavor coming together to create an exceptionally balanced profile. The sweet notes of tropical fruit pair brilliantly with the creamy, spiced backdrop of eggnog, while hints of caramel and brown sugar add an extra layer of indulgence.

7. Lemon Hart & Son Blackpool Spiced Rum [Best Spiced Rum]

Lemon Hart & Son, a legendary name in the rum world, presents the Blackpool Spiced Rum that captivates your palate with a symphony of exotic spices. It boasts an exceptional balance of sugar, salt, and bitter notes, which mingle harmoniously in every sip. The rum originates from Demerara, a region famously known for producing exquisite rums, where the distillate gains a rich and robust flavor with hints of toffee.

The unique combination of caramel, ginger, and sweet spices of Blackpool Spiced Rum makes it a stand-out addition to your eggnog recipe. Expect to indulge your senses with a luxurious texture, amplified by the lingering warm heat of chili and black pepper. No doubt, this spiced rum will make your holiday drink a true delight that's leagues beyond the ordinary.

8. Chairman's Reserve Spiced Rum

Crafted on the lush island of St. Lucia, Chairman's Reserve Spiced Rum is a tribute to the island's exotic flora and vibrant culture. Produced by the St. Lucia Distillers, this rum offers a bold and intense flavor profile that embraces centuries-old traditions. The company's master blend sets the standard for St. Lucian rums, creating a distinctive and smooth-tasting spirit that earns a place among the best-spiced eggnogs.

Infused with a collection of local ingredients, such as cinnamon, nutmeg, mace, orange peel, and lemon zest, the Chairman's Reserve Spiced Rum showcases a beautiful fusion of natural flavors. Combined with a hint of clove and vanilla, this spiced rum adds depth and delightful complexity to your eggnog, ensuring every sip is a celebration of the Caribbean's finest ingredients.

Also Read: Best Rums for Piña Colada

9. Plantation O.F.T.D. Rum

The result of a creative collaboration between numerous rum connoisseurs and award-winning producers, Plantation O.F.T.D. Rum is a truly exceptional spiced rum that is perfect for eggnog. The O.F.T.D. acronym stands for “Old Fashioned Traditional Dark,” a fitting name for this sumptuous blend of Guyanese, Jamaican, and Barbadian rums, aged in Bourbon barrels and bottled at a robust 69% ABV.

Featuring a mix of caramel, toffee, vanilla, and cocoa notes, Plantation O.F.T.D. Rum brings a delightful sweetness to your eggnog, while also packing a powerful spiced punch. Cinnamon, clove, and allspice only enhance the festive spirit in each glass. The deep, dark color and complexity of flavors make this rum the ideal partner to transform a classic eggnog into an exotic and memorable treat.

10. Lemon Hart & Son Original 1804 Rum

Lemon Hart & Son Original 1804 Rum is a stellar choice for those who enjoy a bold and full-bodied flavor in their eggnog. This dark rum, originating from Guyana, is known for its rich molasses base and distinctive notes of treacle, toffee, and brown sugar. A hint of smoky wood and oak reveals itself on the palate, adding complexity and depth, making it an ideal candidate for a robust, satisfying eggnog experience.

When combined with the luxurious creaminess and delicate spice of traditional eggnog, the Lemon Hart & Son Original 1804 Rum imparts an extra layer of warmth that is perfect for sipping by the fire on a cold winter night.

11. Myers's Rum Original Dark

For those who prefer a Jamaican touch in their eggnog, Myers's Rum Original Dark is an excellent choice. This rich, dark rum is crafted from a blend of up to nine different rums, each aged for a specific period to achieve a complex and harmonious balance of flavors. The delectable combination of its notes of caramel, deep molasses, and fruity undertones brings a unique Jamaican flair to your eggnog.

Its bold flavor profile lends itself well to cutting through the richness of eggnog while still allowing the festive flavors of nutmeg, cinnamon, and vanilla to shine. A soothing and distinctive warmth envelopes your palate with each sip, making Myers’s Rum Original Dark a must-try for adventurous eggnog enthusiasts.

12. Coruba Dark Jamaican Rum

Another fantastic offering from the sun-soaked shores of Jamaica is the Coruba Dark Jamaican Rum. This delightfully dark rum boasts a flavor profile that is rich, fruity, and spicy, perfectly complementing the creamy base and sweet spices present in a traditional glass of eggnog.

With bold notes of molasses, dark chocolate, and hints of coffee and tobacco, Coruba Dark Jamaican Rum adds depth and intrigue to the beverage while preserving its comforting essence. The fusion of the rum's unique character with the velvety texture and festive aromatic profile of eggnog creates a match made in holiday heaven.

13. Goslings Black Seal Rum

Goslings Black Seal Rum, hailing from Bermuda, is well known for its signature role in the famous Dark 'n' Stormy cocktail. This iconic dark rum's rich and complex flavor profile, featuring dominant notes of molasses, caramel, and spiced citrus, pairs effortlessly with the delectable, creamy goodness of eggnog.

The enticing mix of sweet, spicy, and fruity flavors in Goslings Black Seal Rum harmonize beautifully with the cinnamon, nutmeg, and whipped cream in eggnog, offering a delightful balance of indulgence and refreshment. A lingering warmth follows each sip, making it a lovely option for turning a simple cup of eggnog into a truly memorable experience.

14. Skipper Demerara Rum

Now, we have the Skipper Demerara Rum, a fine dark rum originating from Guyana, possessing a rich heritage of rum production. A deep brown sugar and molasses base sets the stage for an array of enticing flavors, including hints of licorice, chocolate, and dried fruit.

When paired with the luxurious creaminess and gentle spices of eggnog, the bold and robust flavor profile of Skipper Demerara Rum brings a level of sophistication and indulgence that is hard to beat. The toasty warmth and intriguing layers of flavor in this exceptional rum make it an outstanding choice for creating a delectable glass of eggnog to be enjoyed during the festive holiday season.

15. Appleton Estate Signature [Best Signature Rum]

Appleton Estate Signature is a premium blend of 15 select aged rums from Jamaica's Nassau Valley, each carefully chosen by the Master Blender to create a remarkable expression of the marriage between silky-smooth textures and exquisite flavors.

This rum wields tantalizing aromas of warm cinnamon, nutmeg, and brown sugar, which seamlessly complement the delicate spices traditionally found in Eggnog. On the palate, the rum delivers a symphony of stone fruits, lush vanilla, and vibrant orange zest that elevate the creaminess of the eggnog while maintaining a delightfully balanced sweetness. With a medium body and a lingering, warm finish, Appleton Estate Signature adds depth, complexity, and a touch of the Caribbean to your holiday indulgence.

16. Amrut Old Port Deluxe Matured Rum

Hailing from Bangalore, India, Amrut Old Port Deluxe Matured Rum is a testament to the art of blending molasses and cane juice distillates, resulting in a fascinatingly eccentric rum experience. With a proud heritage dating back to the legendary Amrut Distilleries, this rum brings to your eggnog a bold and innovative approach.

Enticing scents of tropical fruits, toasted oak, and sweet spices meld effortlessly into the egg and cream base, adding an exotic touch to your traditional holiday treat. The taste presents bold notes of rich chocolate, ripe plantains, and a hint of earthy tobacco that harmonize beautifully with the eggnog's creamy disposition. Amrut Old Port Deluxe Matured Rum's long, satisfying finish is a warm embrace that guarantees to make your eggnog a toast to remember.

17. Denizen Vatted Dark Rum

Denizen Vatted Dark Rum is an ambitious creation that captures the essence of three distinctive Caribbean islands: Trinidad, Guyana, and Jamaica. Meticulously hand-selected and blended by expert distillers, this rum offers an adventurous take on a dark and brooding character.

Opening with a stunning bouquet of coffee beans, toasted oak, and rich molasses, Denizen Vatted Dark Rum elegantly enhances the eggnog's luscious sweetness. The flavors unfold into a revelation of ripe cherries, cocoa nibs, and fragrant florals that blend harmoniously with the familiar notes of vanilla, cinnamon, and cloves typical of Eggnog. The bold, assertive nature of this rum beautifully counterbalances the soothing creaminess of eggnog and culminates in a strikingly memorable holiday drink.

18. Plantation Dark Overproof Rum

Plantation Dark Overproof Rum is a masterpiece of blending expertise. Bold, powerful, and deliciously complex, this rum's velvety smoothness defies its overproof status with an impressive 73% ABV. It combines full-bodied Guyanese and Jamaican rum with a delicate balance that creates a superb depth of flavor. This dark, amber-hued beauty is aged in bourbon barrels, infusing the spirit with subtle notes of toasted wood and sweet vanilla.

On the nose, you'll detect enticing aromas of caramel, cinnamon, clove, and tropical fruits. The rich palate is laden with flavors like brown sugar, ripe banana, dried fruits, and oak, ending with a long, warm, and spicy finish. When paired with your homemade eggnog, the Plantation Dark Overproof Rum adds an unparalleled richness and intensity that will linger pleasantly on your palate. The assertive flavors of this rum easily stand up to the delicate sweetness of eggnog while adding dimension and intrigue to every sip.

19. Mount Gay Eclipse

Mount Gay Eclipse is the epitome of harmonious blends, boasting a proud heritage that dates back to 1703 from the world's oldest commercial rum distillery. A versatile and inviting rum, Mount Gay Eclipse is an excellent addition to your holiday eggnog, offering a delightful balance of finesse and accessibility that is sure to appease even the most discerning drinkers.

This Barbadian rum is the perfect expression of a classic amber spirit, with a gentle golden hue that hints at the depth and warmth it brings to your glass. It is expertly crafted using both column and pot still distillation techniques, merging light and complex notes for a seamless, unified taste. Aromatic and engaging, the nose delivers notes of apricot, banana, and raisins, accompanied by the underlying influence of charred oak and spice.

With a pleasing mouthfeel, the Mount Gay Eclipse offers up flavors of smooth vanilla, toasted almond, and ripe fruits, accented by a gentle kiss of spice for a thrilling finish. When combined with eggnog, this rum adds a splendid bouquet of flavors that amplify the rich and creamy characteristics of the beloved holiday beverage.

Also Read: Best Cheap Rums

Considerations When Choosing the Best Rum for Your Eggnog

When it comes to selecting the perfect rum for your eggnog, there is a wide range of options available, each with its own unique characteristics and flavors. To find the best rum for your personal taste and to complement your creamy, festive concoction, consider the following factors:

Personal Taste Preferences

Different rums carry unique flavor profiles, ranging from sweet, spicy, smoky, earthy, to fruity. Understanding your personal taste preference will help you choose the ideal rum for your eggnog. Experiment with different varieties to discover which best suits your palate.

Alcohol Strength

Rums come in various ABV (Alcohol By Volume) percentages, typically around 40%-50%. However, some overproof rums can go as high as 75% ABV. It's essential to monitor the alcohol strength when selecting a rum, to avoid overpowering the flavor of your eggnog or making it too strong.

Types of Rum

There are several main types of rum to choose from, including white, gold, dark, aged, spiced, and flavored rums. Each variety offers a distinct taste and character, reflecting the production techniques and aging methods used. Be sure to select a type that complements the spices, richness, and sweetness of your eggnog.

• White Rum - A lighter, more subtle rum that adds a touch of fruity sweetness without overpowering the eggnog.
• Gold Rum - A more flavorful option with notes of caramel, toffee, and chocolate, complementing the creaminess of eggnog.
• Dark Rum - A rich, robust choice with bold flavors like molasses and coffee, adding a delicious depth to your festive drink.
• Aged Rum - Rums aged in oak barrels for varying durations, imparting complex and bold flavors suited for those seeking a more sophisticated sip.
• Spiced Rum - Infused with spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla, these rums bring the natural flavor of eggnog to the forefront.
• Flavored Rum - A unique option that adds a twist to your traditional eggnog with flavors like coconut, banana, or pineapple.

Budget

Lastly, consider your budget when selecting the best rum for your eggnog. High-quality rums can range from affordable to premium price points. Opting for a rum that fits your budget without sacrificing flavor or quality is essential for the perfect eggnog experience.

How to Mix the Perfect Rum and Eggnog Cocktail?

Crafting the perfect rum and eggnog cocktail is an art that demands precision and finesse. Here, we explore the essential steps to create a delectable drink that you'll relish sip by sip.

Ingredients

1. 2 oz preferred rum (from our selection of the best rums for eggnog)
2. 4-6 oz store-bought or homemade eggnog
3. Freshly grated nutmeg (for garnishing)
4. Optional ingridients (whipped cream, cinnamon stick, or shaved chocolate)

Instructions

1. Choose the right glass. A traditional rocks glass or a festive holiday-themed glass will work well for serving your rum and eggnog cocktail.
2. Pour the rum. Add 2 oz of your selected rum to the glass.
3. Fill the glass. Top with 4-6 oz of eggnog, depending on the size of your glass and your personal preference for the rum-to-eggnog ratio.
4. Mix it up. Use a cocktail spoon to gently stir the rum and eggnog until they are well combined.
5. Add ice. Fill the glass with ice, if desired. (Tip: You can use a large ice cube or sphere to avoid diluting the drink too quickly)
6. Garnish and serve. Finish off by lightly dusting the top with freshly grated nutmeg and adding any other optional garnishes of your choice. Savor and share your delightful creation!

What Makes a Rum Ideal for Eggnog: Understanding the Basics

Selecting the perfect rum to pair with eggnog can truly elevate the whole drinking experience. To better understand why certain rums shine in this classic cocktail, let's delve into some basic elements that contribute to a rum's suitability for eggnog.

Flavor Profile

• The best rums for eggnog possess a well-balanced flavor profile, often with rich, sweet, and spicy notes that harmonize with the beverage's creaminess. Avoid overpowering or excessively sweet rums, as they can throw off the delicate balance of flavors.

Distillation Process

• Rums are typically produced through two primary methods: pot still or column still distillation. Pot-distilled rums tend to be heavier and more full-bodied, making them a preferred choice for eggnog. Column-distilled rums, on the other hand, are lighter and crisper, which may not offer the same depth of flavor as their pot still counterparts.

Aging and Maturation

• Aged rums are often admired for their depth and character, which bring an extra layer of complexity to eggnog. The aging process imparts unique flavors from the barrels in which the rum is matured, such as oak, vanilla, and caramel notes that beautifully complement the velvety richness and spices of eggnog.

Why the Quality of Rum Matters in Eggnog: Uncovering the Secrets

When it comes to crafting delectable eggnog, the quality of the rum you choose can make all the difference. There are several reasons why opting for a high-quality rum will enhance your festive drink:

Enhanced Overall Taste

A top-notch rum brings its own unique characteristics and intricate nuances, which blend harmoniously with the creamy and sweet components of eggnog. By choosing a high-quality rum, you're elevating the overall taste of your drink and making it an unforgettable experience for your taste buds.

Bold Flavor Combinations: Quality rums offer bold flavor combinations that mingle effortlessly with the eggnog. These distinctive flavors add dimension to the drink, making it taste richer and more satisfying.

Balance of Flavors

The key to a perfect eggnog lies in the delicate balance of flavors. Using a quality rum ensures that the taste of alcohol neither overpowers nor fades into the background. Instead, it seamlessly marries with the other ingredients to create a luxurious harmony.

Unrivaled Smoothness: High-quality rums boast a smooth texture, which pairs beautifully with the creamy base of eggnog. By choosing a refined rum, you're ensuring a velvety, melt-in-your-mouth sensation with every single sip.

Improved Texture and Richness

Quality rums often possess an unparalleled richness that can contribute to the overall texture of the drink. This lusciousness translates into a thicker, more indulgent eggnog that feels undeniably festive.

Emphasis on Body and Mouthfeel: Investing in a top-tier rum adds depth and body to your eggnog, making it feel like a true holiday indulgence rather than just another beverage.

Overall, the quality of rum you choose for your eggnog can significantly affect the final result. Splurging on a superior rum is a small investment that will ultimately enhance your festive creation and make the holiday season even more special.

Why Enjoying Rum and Eggnog Responsibly is Essential?

The holiday season is full of joy and celebration, but it's also a time to be mindful of our alcohol consumption. As the rich flavors of rum and eggnog tend to be highly addictive, it's essential to enjoy this delightful combination responsibly.

• Limit your intake: While sipping on a glass of fragrant, velvety eggnog may bring immense pleasure, it's important to be aware of its alcohol content and limit your intake. Monitoring your consumption ensures that you enjoy the holiday beverage without overindulging.
• Designate a driver: If you're attending a gathering where rum and eggnog (or other alcoholic beverages) are being served, make sure to have a designated driver or plan for alternative transportation methods (such as rideshare services). By doing so, you play a crucial role in creating a safe environment for everyone on the road.
• Encourage hydration: Pairing your rum and eggnog with plenty of water is an important step in responsible drinking. Properly hydrating between alcoholic beverages can help mitigate the negative effects of alcohol and ensure a more enjoyable experience for everyone.
• Be mindful of those around you: Remember that not everyone consumes alcohol, and respecting their choices creates an inclusive atmosphere for everyone to enjoy. Offer a selection of non-alcoholic eggnog alternatives to cater to those who prefer alcohol-free options.

It's essential to enjoy the delightful pairing of rum and eggnog responsibly by being mindful of our consumption, the well-being of others, and safety measures during the holiday season. These small yet meaningful actions will contribute to a more enjoyable, inclusive, and memorable celebration for all.

Also Read: Best Dominican Republic Rums

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

As we raise our glasses to the holiday season, it's clear that selecting the perfect rum truly enhances the overall enjoyment of our cherished eggnog. Whether you prefer the complexity of aged rums, the kick of spiced blends, or the unique profile of lesser-known gems, the key to a heavenly eggnog experience lies in your adventurous spirit and willingness to explore the world of rum. Just as the holidays bring people together and create lasting memories, so can a beautifully crafted rum and eggnog cocktail.

So, this festive season, gather your loved ones, indulge in a glass of your favorite pairing, and savor the enchanting flavors that make the holidays so magical. May every sip of your eggnog brim with the warmth, love, and joy that these best rums have to offer!