3 Best Peppermint Ice Cream Brands of 2024 [Scoop It Up]

There's something so uniquely refreshing about peppermint ice cream. It's that unparalleled mix of cool mint and sumptuous cream, a palette-awakening concoction that makes us feel indulged, soothed, and utterly satisfied. Whether it's the heart of a balmy summer or the depth of a chilly winter, the joy of digging into a tub of the best peppermint ice cream is comparably unrivaled. It's a symphony of flavors that dances on your taste buds and leaves you longing for another spoonful.

Combine that with the special allure of magical, sweet peppermint and you'll find yourself in a dessert lover’s paradise. Diving into this beautiful confluence of tastes, today, we'll uncover some of my personal favorite picks of the best peppermint ice cream brands that are sure to transport you to a world of creamy, minty delight.

Also Read: Best Jeni's Ice Cream Flavors

3 Best Peppermint Ice Cream Brands of 2024

Delve into the delicious world of dessert with a rundown of the top three best peppermint ice cream varieties. From the light and crisp to the rich and robust, these ice cream brands will take your love for this minty treat up several notches. Gear up for a culinary journey that's fresh, fun, and flavorsome!

1. Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream

Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream is, in short, a flavorful revelation. Desserts can often feel heavy, leaving us with a sense of guilt and calorie counting. This ice cream puts to rest any such worries.

It’s light, both in terms of calories and taste. Now, don’t let the word 'light' misguide you. It's not by any means a compromise on the taste. On the contrary, it’s an exquisite exploration of something that feels indulgent without being too overwhelming.

Every spoonful of Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream unfurls a symphony of flavors on your palate. With its smooth, creamy texture, it almost feels like biting into a cloud of minty delight—an experience that is both novel and beautiful.

The ice cream also presents a delicate hit of peppermint that is both refreshing and punchy in just the right measure. Not overpoweringly minty nor blandly sweet, the peppermint flavor strikes a harmonious balance amidst the familiar creaminess of the ice cream.

Personally, what stands out for me are the tiny pieces of candy cane sprinkled throughout the ice cream. Besides adding a delightful crunch, they provide an extra peppermint oomph that ties the whole dessert together.

There's something wonderful about looking forward to that unexpected crunch in your ice cream, like stumbling upon a hidden treasure - except in this case, the treasure is additional peppermint flavor! Just a warning, the thrill of the crunch might be slightly addictive.

Consuming this ice cream is akin to taking a therapeutic, sensory journey. The initial creaminess that cushions your taste buds, followed by the abrupt but welcome crunch of the candy cane pieces, and finally, the resounding notes of peppermint that reverberate long after you've taken a bite—it's a rollercoaster of gustatory emotions, one you'll find joy in riding again and again.

From an aesthetic point of view, Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream is just as appealing. The sight of the luxuriously creamy ice cream speckled with pieces of candy cane offers a feast for the eyes, raising the anticipation for the first bite.

An added advantage to this peppermint ice cream is its versatility. It doesn't confine you within the boundaries of a dessert-specific time. Be it for a quick post-lunch treat or a late-night craving, this light peppermint ice cream can be enjoyed anytime, guilt-free.

The delicious allure of Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream is indeed hard to resist. It catapults the humble peppermint ice cream into a one-of-a-kind gastronomic experience.

It's the kind of ice cream you'd want to tuck into after a long day at work or that special indulgence you save for the weekends. It is a testament to the fact that 'light' can be just as indulgent as its richer counterparts.

Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream is a masterstroke in the world of ice creams and desserts—it redefines what it means to be light, to be indulgent, and, most importantly, to be refreshingly minty.

This bewitching confluence of textures, flavors, and sensory delight makes this ice cream a must-try for all peppermint lovers. I promise you; that each bite will make you fall in love with this ice cream all over again.

So, if you have been searching for the best peppermint ice cream, something light yet indulgent, look no further than Signature Select Light Peppermint Ice Cream. Your taste buds will thank you for the treat.

2. Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream

Imagine biting into a luscious blend of mint and chocolate, quite literally, a mouthful of yuletide joy – that's what you get when you delve into the tempting world of Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream.

This ice cream is for those of you who love a rich, minty intensity in your desserts. It doesn’t cut corners when it comes to the peppermint flavor; it is meant for those who not only appreciate but crave a robust pepperminty allure. From the moment you open the tub, the scent of crisp peppermint fills the air, setting up the stage for a true indulgence.

Every bite of the Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream is like taking a deep dive into a chilly, delicious winter wonderland. It speaks of unhindered decadence and the audacious pleasure of rewarding oneself with something truly special.

In the wide world of ice creams, where peppermint can sometimes take the backseat, it is refreshing to find a dessert that puts peppermint right where it belongs – in the spotlight, unapologetically triumphant.

What takes this ice cream to the next level, though, is the peppermint bark element. The presence of these chunky pieces of peppermint bark – a divine concoction of peppermint and chocolate – makes each spoonful an adventure. The textures play a delightful game of crunch and creaminess, of cocoa and cool mint, creating a striking contrast that’s simply irresistible.

Another standout attribute is the potency of the flavors. The robust peppermint, combined with the rich chocolate, guarantees that this isn't just ice cream—it’s a taste explosion. There are no subtle hints or gentle nudges; everything is unashamedly bold and thoroughly satisfying.

As for appearance, this ice cream is quite a visual treat as well. The sight of the vibrant ice cream punctuated by chunks of dark chocolate peppermint bark is a joy to behold.

When it comes to versatility, Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream scores pretty high. Sure, it can definitely stand as a dessert of its own, but it also pairs well with other goodies. Imagine a warm brownie topped with a dollop of this ice cream — the warmth of the brownie melting the ice cream, resulting in rivers of creamy, minty goodness that soak through your dessert.

The beauty of this ice cream is wrapped up in the power of its intensity. If you're someone who loves capturing the essence of flavors in their most potent forms, then the Favorite Day Peppermint Bark is the perfect fit for you.

In the grand scheme of ice creams and desserts, the Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream stands out like a beacon. Intense, rich, and loaded with all things peppermint, there’s so much this ice cream has to offer.

Sure, it might be 'just ice cream,' but when something as every day as ice cream is transformed into a memorable, sensory experience like the Favorite Day Peppermint Bark Ice Cream, you simply can’t help but appreciate the transformation. So, take a bite and let this refreshing symphony of mint and chocolate win over your taste buds.

Also Read: Best Tillamook Ice Cream Flavors

3. Alden’s Peppermint Twist

The classic taste of peppermint, and the comfort of a traditional ice cream, all wrapped into one delightful package—that’s the essence of Alden’s Peppermint Twist. Alden's has always been known for their quality ingredients and unparalleled flavor combinations, and this ice cream unequivocally attests to that reputation.

From the moment you spoon it out, you are greeted with a cheerful blush pink hue, a visual representation of the sweet treat you’re about to indulge in. And indulgence it indeed is!

Upon the first taste, you are introduced to a delightful, smooth texture that feels like velvet against the palette. It cascades over your tongue and leaves a hint of sweetness, a whisper of cool mint, that has you reaching for more, spoonful after lavish spoonful.

In terms of flavor, Alden’s Peppermint Twist paints a picture of elegant subtlety rather than robust boldness. The peppermint is present, undeniably so, but it doesn’t thrust itself upon your senses. Instead, it sits there gently, patiently, waiting for you to explore it at your own pace. It's what makes this ice cream such a winning choice among those who prefer a more balanced, less in-your-face dessert experience.

But do not mistake its subtlety for lack of character. On the contrary, Alden’s Peppermint Twist possesses a charm that is entirely its own. The beauty is in the details—the tiny bits of candy cane that appear now and then, providing a playful crunch, complementing the softness of the ice cream. It’s in the slight pink blush of color, which elevates the overall aesthetic allure of the treat.

The best part, of course, is savoring the entire experience. Sitting back with a tub of Alden’s Peppermint Twist, you get to enjoy not just the taste, but the feeling of comfort, the whisper of happiness that comes from indulging in something truly delicious.

Its classic flavor profile makes it a versatile beauty. Whether you serve it atop a freshly baked apple pie, use it to craft an irresistible milkshake, or simply enjoy it by the spoonful, Alden’s Peppermint Twist turns any occasion into a celebration.

Alden’s Peppermint Twist turns an ordinary dessert moment into an extraordinary one. Its delicate balance of flavors, the subtle nuance, the play of texture and color—all come together to make this ice cream a must-try. So the next time you find yourself yearning for a peppermint ice cream that hits all the right notes and then some, know that Alden’s Peppermint Twist is waiting for you.

How is the Best Peppermint Ice Cream Made?

Crafting the perfect peppermint ice cream is an art that speaks volumes about the meticulous attention to detail involved. It's a delicious journey from the most basic, yet top-quality ingredients - milk, cream, sugar, and of course, the magic component, peppermint.

Selecting Prime Ingredients

The journey begins with sourcing the highest quality of ingredients. The base of the ice cream ideally consists of full-fat milk and cream to achieve that rich, velvety texture. The type of sugar used can also make a difference. Traditional granulated sugar is often used, but some artisanal makers may use alternative sweeteners like agave nectar or honey.

Art of Infusion

Then comes the star, the peppermint. There are two ways to introduce the mint flavor. One way is using fresh peppermint leaves. This involves a process of steeping the leaves in the dairy, much like making a peppermint tea, to extract the flavors before straining them out. The alternative is to use a pure peppermint extract. The secret here is to ensure the balance is right. Too much can overpower, and too little can disappoint.

Churning and Freezing

Once the mint-infused mixture is sweetened, it's time to churn. This not only freezes the ice cream but aerates it as well, providing that crucial light, yet creamy texture. Lastly, the craftsmen often sprinkle pieces of peppermint candy or dark chocolate chips to add that extra dimension of texture and flavor.

Why Peppermint Ice Cream Stands Out?

Peppermint ice cream is more than just a dessert- it's an experience, a delightful symphony of flavors and sensations that tantalize your taste buds.

Unique Taste Adventure

When you take that first divine spoonful of peppermint ice cream, you are greeted with a refreshing coolness that is distinctly peppermint. It's a bright, invigorating flavor that cuts perfectly through the creaminess of the ice cream base, creating a dessert that manages to be indulgent yet light and refreshing.

Balance of Flavours

The element that truly makes peppermint ice cream stand out, however, is the unique balance of flavors. With most other ice creams, you encounter a continuous sweet profile. But peppermint ice cream takes you by surprise. It's a perfect blend of sweet and cool - a rare find on the dessert menu. Throw in some candy canes or chocolate chips, and you have a burst of extra texture that elevates the whole taste journey.

Basically, peppermint ice cream extricates itself from the rest by being an enchanting mix of refreshing, sweet, and creamy all at once. It is a true palate cleanser and stands tall amid the ice cream crowd with its unique flavor profile that is sure to whisk you on a chilly, delight-filled adventure.

How to Pair Your Favorite Peppermint Ice Cream?

Peppermint ice cream is undeniably delicious on its own, but pairing it with other foods and drinks can truly elevate your culinary experience. Here are some creative ways to enjoy your favorite minty delight:

Dessert Pairings

Peppermint ice cream pairs exceptionally well with chocolate-based desserts. Consider serving a scoop with decadent brownies or a slice of chocolate cake. Likewise, it's a fantastic contrast with fruit-based desserts like raspberry or strawberry pie. The tartness of the fruit mixed with the coolness of the peppermint is heavenly.

Drink Pairings

Pair peppermint ice cream with steaming hot cocoa for a treat that’s both warming and cooling at the same time. You can also explore pairing it with mint tea or a cool mint julep cocktail for an extra minty experience.

As for wine lovers, a dessert wine or port can complement the sweetness and complexity of peppermint ice cream.

Also Read: Best Mochi Ice Cream Flavors

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

So, there you have it - three stellar choices to quench your cravings for the best peppermint ice cream. Whether it's the guilt-free indulgence of Signature Select, the flavor-packed Favorite Day, or the classic allure of Alden’s Peppermint Twist, each one brings its own delight to the table. But remember, the best ice cream is one that satisfies your personal palate. So, go ahead and treat yourself—you never know, your taste buds may just throw you a thank-you party.

Bring on the spoon and the bowl, it's time for some ice cream delight. So, indulge in the minty magic, let the creamy texture soothe you, and revel in the magnificence of a fabulous peppermint ice cream. Life is short, eat dessert first, and make it a peppermint ice cream.