8 Best Peppermint Ice Cream Brands (June 2026) Tested

There is something magical about that first spoonful of peppermint ice cream during the holiday season. The cool mint flavor combined with crunchy candy pieces creates a festive treat that has become a winter tradition in many households. If you are searching for the best peppermint ice cream brands to enjoy this season, you have come to the right place.

Our team spent weeks sampling mint-flavored frozen desserts from major brands and artisan producers to bring you this comprehensive guide. We evaluated everything from texture and mint intensity to mix-in quality and overall value. Whether you prefer the classic pink peppermint stick variety or the more decadent peppermint bark style with white chocolate, we have recommendations that will satisfy your craving.

From creamy gelato to organic options and budget-friendly picks, we tested them all. We even discovered some year-round options for those who refuse to wait until November to enjoy this beloved flavor. If you want to explore more premium frozen treats, check out our guide to the best Jeni’s ice cream flavors for additional inspiration.

Top 3 Peppermint Ice Cream Picks by Sixstoreys

Best Peppermint Ice Cream Brands in 2026

1. Talenti Mediterranean Mint Gelato – Creamiest Texture

When I first opened the jar of Talenti Mediterranean Mint Gelato, I noticed immediately that it looked different from other mint ice creams. There is no artificial green coloring here. The gelato has a natural off-white color that comes from using real ingredients rather than food dyes.

The texture is where this gelato truly shines. Talenti uses a slow-churned process that creates a dense, velvety consistency that coats your tongue. Unlike some ice creams that feel airy or whipped, this gelato has a luxurious weight to it that makes each spoonful feel indulgent.

What sets Talenti apart is their steeping process. They steep real mint leaves for 45 full minutes in fresh milk, cream, and sugar before churning. This creates an authentic mint flavor that tastes like fresh mint rather than artificial extract. The bittersweet chocolate chips scattered throughout provide a perfect contrast to the cool mint base.

After testing this gelato alongside other brands, I found myself reaching for it repeatedly. The balance between the fresh mint flavor and chocolate is spot on. Neither overpowers the other, and the chocolate chunks are generously sized rather than tiny specks you can barely taste.

Best served with

This gelato pairs beautifully with a warm brownie or chocolate cake. The temperature contrast between the cold gelato and warm dessert creates a wonderful experience. I also tried it with crushed candy cane pieces sprinkled on top for extra crunch during the holidays.

For a simple but elegant dessert, serve a scoop in a chilled bowl with a drizzle of hot fudge. The combination of the creamy gelato, rich chocolate sauce, and embedded chocolate chips creates a triple-chocolate mint experience that is hard to beat.

Availability and storage

Talenti is widely available at most major grocery stores including Target, Walmart, and Whole Foods. The clear plastic jars make it easy to see exactly what you are getting. Store it in the coldest part of your freezer and let it sit at room temperature for about 5 minutes before scooping for the best texture.

2. 365 by Whole Foods Market Mint Chocolate Chip – Best Value

The 365 by Whole Foods Market Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream delivers impressive quality at a reasonable price point. This 1.5 quart tub provides plenty of servings, making it an excellent choice for families or anyone who goes through ice cream quickly.

I was pleased to find that Whole Foods maintains their quality standards even in their store brand. The ice cream is certified gluten-free, kosher, and vegetarian. Most importantly for mint lovers, it contains no artificial green coloring. The ice cream has a natural white appearance rather than the unnaturally bright green you see in some brands.

The mint flavor hits a sweet spot. It is present and refreshing without venturing into toothpaste territory. Some mint ice creams go overboard with the flavoring, but this one stays balanced. The chocolate chips are plentiful and provide a satisfying crunch with each bite.

Texture-wise, this ice cream is light and fluffy rather than dense. It scoops easily straight from the freezer and has a pleasant mouthfeel. While it may not have the ultra-premium density of gelato, it offers a classic American ice cream experience that many people prefer.

Texture and consistency

The texture leans toward the lighter side compared to premium brands. This makes it easier to scoop and gives it a softer consistency even when properly frozen. Some ice cream enthusiasts prefer this style, while others might find it less rich than higher-butterfat options.

I noticed that the chocolate chips are smaller than some competing brands. While this means they distribute more evenly throughout the ice cream, those who prefer large chocolate chunks might be slightly disappointed. The trade-off is that you get chocolate in nearly every bite.

Flavor intensity

The mint intensity is moderate. It is definitely noticeable but not overwhelming. This makes it a good choice for serving to guests with varying preferences. Kids tend to enjoy it, and adults appreciate that it does not taste like candy. If you prefer a stronger mint kick, you might want to add some crushed candy canes as a topping.

3. Ben & Jerry’s Mint Chocolate Cookie – Best Mix-Ins

Ben & Jerry’s takes a different approach with their Mint Chocolate Cookie flavor. Instead of chocolate chips, they mix in actual chocolate sandwich cookies throughout the peppermint ice cream. This creates a completely different experience from traditional mint chocolate chip varieties.

The first time I scooped this ice cream, I was surprised to find an entire cookie in my bowl. Ben & Jerry’s is known for being generous with their mix-ins, and this flavor is no exception. The cookies add a wonderful textural element with their crunchy edges and soft creme filling.

Beyond the creative mix-ins, Ben & Jerry’s maintains their commitment to ethical sourcing. The cocoa and sugar are Fairtrade certified, and all ingredients are sourced from non-GMO suppliers. The eggs used are cage-free, which matters to many conscious consumers.

Mix-in quality

The chocolate sandwich cookies are the star of this show. They maintain their crunch even when frozen, and the contrast between the chocolate cookie exterior and vanilla creme center adds complexity to each bite. I found the distribution to be excellent, with cookies appearing throughout the pint.

Some reviewers have noted that the cookie-to-ice-cream ratio can feel heavy on the cookies. If you prefer your ice cream to be mostly ice cream with occasional mix-ins, this might not be your first choice. However, if you love finding chunks and pieces in every spoonful, this delivers in spades.

Ethical sourcing

Ben & Jerry’s has built their brand on social responsibility, and this flavor reflects those values. The Fairtrade certification ensures that farmers receive fair prices for their cocoa and sugar. For consumers who want to enjoy ice cream while supporting ethical supply chains, this is a solid choice.

4. Breyers Mint Chocolate Chip – Classic Choice

Breyers Mint Chocolate Chip represents the classic American ice cream experience that many of us grew up with. This 48-ounce tub is made with 100% Grade A milk and cream, and the company has over 150 years of ice cream making experience behind it.

What immediately stands out is that Breyers uses real mint extract rather than artificial flavoring. This gives the ice cream an authentic taste that has remained consistent over the years. The ice cream is also free from artificial green dye, appearing naturally white with dark chocolate chips throughout.

The texture is smooth and creamy, though not as dense as premium brands. This lighter consistency makes it easy to scoop and gives it a classic ice cream mouthfeel. The chocolate chips are well-distributed and provide a nice contrast to the cool mint base.

I appreciate that Breyers keeps their ingredient list relatively simple. The non-GMO sourced ingredients and gluten-free certification make this accessible to many dietary needs. It is a reliable choice that delivers exactly what you expect from a mainstream ice cream brand.

Natural ingredients

Breyers prides itself on using high-quality ingredients. The real mint extract provides a refreshing flavor without tasting chemical or artificial. The 100% Grade A milk and cream create a solid base, though the lower butterfat content compared to premium brands results in a lighter texture.

The absence of artificial green coloring is worth noting. Many mint ice creams use food dye to achieve that characteristic green color. Breyers skips this entirely, resulting in a pure white ice cream that looks natural and appetizing.

Nostalgic appeal

For many people, Breyers represents childhood memories of ice cream. The brand has maintained its identity over decades, and the taste remains familiar. If you are looking for that classic mint chocolate chip experience you remember from growing up, this delivers exactly that.

5. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Mint Chip – Organic Option

The 365 Organic Mint Chip Ice Cream offers a certified organic option for those who prioritize organic ingredients in their frozen desserts. This 16-ounce pint delivers quality at an affordable price point compared to other organic ice cream brands.

I found the mint flavor to be well-balanced and not overpowering. The ice cream has a creamy texture with medium-large chocolate chunks distributed throughout. For those seeking organic certification without the premium price tag of artisanal brands, this is an excellent choice.

Like its non-organic counterpart, this ice cream contains no artificial dyes. The natural white color indicates the absence of artificial green coloring that appears in many mainstream brands. This is a plus for parents trying to limit artificial ingredients in their children’s diets.

The chocolate chunks are a highlight. They are larger than what you find in many competing brands and provide a satisfying bite. The organic chocolate has a rich flavor that pairs well with the mint base.

Organic benefits

Choosing organic ice cream means avoiding pesticides and genetically modified ingredients. The USDA organic certification ensures that the milk, cream, and other ingredients meet strict organic farming standards. For health-conscious consumers, this provides peace of mind about what they are eating.

The certification also covers gluten-free and vegetarian status, making this accessible to those with dietary restrictions. Whole Foods maintains their quality standards throughout their 365 product line.

Chocolate quality

The chocolate chunks in this ice cream are noticeably larger than in many competitors. They provide real chocolate flavor rather than just sweetness. The organic chocolate has a depth that enhances the overall experience, especially when you get a particularly chunky bite.

6. Jeni’s Green Mint Chip – Premium Artisan

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams has built a reputation for exceptional quality, and their Green Mint Chip lives up to that standard. This premium pint features Direct Trade chocolate from Askinosie in Missouri and organic ingredients throughout.

The first thing I noticed was the texture. Jeni’s achieves a perfect balance between dense and creamy. The ice cream coats your tongue luxuriously without feeling heavy. This is artisan ice cream at its finest, made in small batches with careful attention to detail.

The mint flavor is clean and refreshing without being cloying. Jeni’s uses real mint rather than artificial flavoring, which creates a more sophisticated taste profile. The dark chocolate pieces scattered throughout provide a rich counterpoint to the cool mint.

Premium ingredients

Jeni’s commitment to quality shows in their ingredient sourcing. The Direct Trade chocolate comes from specific farms, ensuring both quality and fair compensation for farmers. This is chocolate you can feel good about eating, and you can taste the difference in quality.

The organic certification covers the dairy and other ingredients. Jeni’s builds their ice cream from scratch using high-quality components rather than pre-made bases. This attention to detail results in a cleaner, more refined flavor.

Best occasions

This is ice cream for special occasions or when you want to treat yourself. The premium price point reflects the quality ingredients and artisanal production. Save this for evenings when you can truly savor it rather than mindless snacking.

7. Van Leeuwen Mint Chip – Brooklyn Artisan

Van Leeuwen brings Brooklyn artisanal ice cream making to the masses with their Mint Chip flavor. The company makes all their ice cream from scratch in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, using a handful of fresh ingredients.

The classic scoops are crafted with nothing more than fresh milk and cream, cane sugar, and egg yolks. This simplicity allows the quality of each ingredient to shine through. The result is ice cream that tastes fresh and pure.

I was struck by how creamy this ice cream is. Van Leeuwen achieves a texture that rivals the best gelato. The fresh mint taste comes through clearly without being overwhelming. This is ice cream for people who appreciate subtlety and quality over flashy mix-ins.

The company also produces vegan versions of their flavors using house-made cashew milk and organic coconut milk. While this particular pint is their classic dairy version, knowing they offer alternatives is helpful for those with dietary restrictions.

Artisan quality

Van Leeuwen started as an ice cream truck in Brooklyn and has grown into a respected artisan brand. Their commitment to quality has remained consistent even as they have expanded. Each pint reflects the care that goes into small-batch production.

The ingredient list is refreshingly short. In an era of complex formulations and additives, Van Leeuwen keeps it simple. This transparency about what goes into their ice cream builds trust with consumers who care about what they eat.

Freshness factor

Because Van Leeuwen makes their ice cream fresh rather than in massive industrial batches, there is a vitality to the flavor that mass-produced brands sometimes lack. The mint tastes like it was added recently rather than sitting in a warehouse for months.

8. Chocolate Shoppe Peppermint Stick – Regional Favorite

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream hails from Wisconsin, a state known for its dairy excellence. Their Peppermint Stick ice cream showcases the rich, creamy texture that Wisconsin ice cream is famous for. This is ice cream for serious peppermint lovers.

The texture is remarkably smooth, even compared to other peppermint stick varieties. The red and green peppermint syrup distributes perfectly throughout, creating a visually appealing swirl pattern. Each spoonful delivers consistent flavor without concentrated pockets of sweetness.

Some reviewers have called this the best ice cream in America, and while that is subjective, the quality is undeniable. The richness comes from high butterfat content and careful production methods. This is indulgent ice cream meant to be savored slowly.

Be aware that this product ships as an 8-pint package, which represents a significant investment. However, for true peppermint ice cream enthusiasts or those wanting to stock up for the season, having eight pints in the freezer ensures you will not run out during the holidays.

Regional specialty

Wisconsin has a long tradition of exceptional dairy production, and Chocolate Shoppe continues that heritage. The company has been making ice cream since 1962, developing recipes that showcase premium dairy ingredients. This is regional ice cream at its finest.

The peppermint stick style differs from mint chocolate chip. Instead of chocolate pieces, you get ribbons of peppermint candy syrup running through the ice cream. This creates a different experience focused on pure peppermint flavor without the chocolate element.

Bulk buying considerations

The 8-pint minimum might seem like a lot, but peppermint ice cream freezes well for months. If you love this flavor and want to enjoy it beyond the typical November-January window, stocking up makes sense. The packaging is designed to keep the ice cream frozen during shipping.

Buying Guide: What to Look for in Peppermint Ice Cream

Choosing the right peppermint ice cream involves more than just grabbing the first tub you see. Understanding the factors that affect taste, texture, and overall satisfaction will help you find the perfect pint for your preferences.

The first consideration is the type of peppermint ice cream you want. Traditional peppermint stick features pink or white ice cream with red and green candy pieces or syrup swirls. Peppermint bark varieties typically have a white chocolate base with chocolate pieces and candy cane bits. Each style offers a different experience.

Texture considerations

Texture varies significantly between brands and styles. Gelato tends to be denser and creamier due to lower overrun (the amount of air whipped into the ice cream). American-style ice cream is lighter and fluffier. Premium brands often have higher butterfat content, creating a richer mouthfeel.

Pay attention to how the ice cream scoops. Some brands are rock-hard straight from the freezer, while others remain scoopable. This affects both convenience and the eating experience. Gelato and premium brands often benefit from sitting at room temperature for a few minutes before serving.

Mint intensity preferences

Mint intensity varies widely between brands. Some deliver a subtle hint of mint that complements rather than dominates. Others pack a powerful peppermint punch that some might find overwhelming. If you are unsure about your preference, start with a moderate option like the 365 by Whole Foods or Breyers.

Consider who will be eating the ice cream. Children often prefer milder mint flavors, while adults might appreciate more intensity. If you are serving a crowd, a middle-ground option tends to please the most people.

Seasonal vs year-round availability

Most peppermint ice cream is seasonal, appearing in stores from late October through early January. If you want peppermint ice cream outside this window, your options become more limited. Some brands offer mint chocolate chip year-round, but true peppermint stick with candy pieces is typically a holiday exclusive.

Planning ahead helps. Stock up during the season if you have freezer space. Some online retailers ship peppermint ice cream year-round, though shipping costs can be significant. For more seasonal ice cream options, check out our guide to the best Tillamook ice cream flavors which includes their popular Peppermint Bark.

Price and value assessment

Ice cream prices range from budget-friendly store brands to premium artisan pints. Consider price per serving rather than just the sticker price. A premium pint might cost more but deliver a more satisfying experience, meaning you eat less at a time.

Value also depends on your priorities. If organic certification matters to you, the extra cost for organic ice cream represents good value. If you just want a tasty treat, mainstream brands offer excellent quality at lower prices.

For those interested in creating their own frozen treats at home, our guide to the best ice cream makers can help you get started. You can also explore Trader Joe’s frozen desserts for unique options like their popular Candy Cane Joe-Joe’s ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions About Peppermint Ice Cream

Conclusion

Finding the best peppermint ice cream brands comes down to understanding your own preferences for texture, mint intensity, and mix-ins. Our top pick, Talenti Mediterranean Mint Gelato, delivers exceptional quality with real mint leaves and velvety texture. For budget-conscious shoppers, the 365 by Whole Foods Mint Chocolate Chip offers great value without sacrificing quality.

Whether you prefer the creative cookie mix-ins from Ben & Jerry’s, the organic certification of 365 Organic Mint Chip, or the artisan quality of Van Leeuwen and Jeni’s, there is a peppermint ice cream perfect for your taste. Stock up during the holiday season and enjoy this festive frozen treat all winter long.